Home Battery Backup vs Generator: Which One Is Right for You? - SHIELDEN

Home Battery Backup vs Generator: Which One Is Right for You?

Have you ever experienced a power outage at your home? If you have, you know how frustrating and inconvenient it can be. You may lose access to essential appliances, devices, and services, such as lighting, heating, cooling, refrigeration, cooking, internet, phone, and security systems. You may also face potential health and safety risks, such as food spoilage, water contamination, fire hazards, and medical emergencies.

That’s why having a backup power solution for your home is a smart and prudent decision. A backup power solution can provide you with reliable and continuous electricity when the grid fails, allowing you to maintain your comfort, convenience, and security. But which backup power solution is right for you? There are two main options to choose from: home battery backup and generator.

Home battery backup and generator are both devices that can store and supply electricity to your home when the grid is down. However, they have different features, advantages, and disadvantages that you need to consider before making a purchase. In this blog, we will compare home battery backup and generator in terms of pricing, installation, maintenance, and performance, and help you decide which one is best suited for your needs and preferences.

Pricing

One of the first factors to consider when choosing a backup power solution is the cost. The cost of a backup power solution can be divided into two categories: upfront and ongoing.

Upfront Cost

The upfront cost is the amount of money you need to pay to purchase and install the backup power solution. The upfront cost of home battery backup and a generator can vary depending on the size, capacity, brand, and quality of the product. Generally speaking, a home battery backup tends to have a higher upfront cost than a generator. For example, a Tesla Powerwall, one of the most popular home battery backup products, costs around $12,000 to $15,000, including installation. A Generac Guardian, one of the most popular generator products, costs around $4,000 to $5,000, including installation.Of course, if you want to save costs, you can also choose DIY Home Battery Backup.

However, the upfront cost of a home battery backup can be reduced by taking advantage of the incentives and rebates offered by the federal, state, and local governments, as well as utility companies. These incentives and rebates are designed to encourage the adoption of renewable energy and energy storage systems, such as home battery backup. For example, the federal Investment Tax Credit (ITC) allows you to deduct 26% of the cost of a home battery backup from your federal income taxes, as long as the battery is charged by solar panels. Some states, such as California, New York, and Massachusetts, also offer additional incentives and rebates for home battery backup systems.

Ongoing Cost

The ongoing cost is the amount of money you need to pay to operate and maintain the backup power solution. The ongoing cost of a home battery backup and a generator can also vary depending on the usage, efficiency, and lifespan of the product. Generally speaking, a home battery backup tends to have a lower ongoing cost than a generator. This is because a home battery backup can be charged by solar panels or the grid during off-peak hours, when the electricity rates are lower. A generator, on the other hand, requires fuel, such as gasoline, propane, or natural gas, to run, which can be expensive and subject to price fluctuations. For example, a typical generator can consume around $20 to $40 worth of fuel per day, depending on the size and load. A home battery backup can also last longer than a generator, reducing the need for replacement. For example, a Tesla Powerwall has a warranty of 10 years, while a Generac Guardian has a warranty of 5 years .

Installation

Another factor to consider when choosing a backup power solution is the installation process and requirements. The installation process and requirements of a home battery backup and a generator can differ depending on the type, size, location, and configuration of the product. Generally speaking, a home battery backup tends to have a simpler and easier installation process than a generator. This is because a home battery backup is usually smaller, lighter, and quieter than a generator, and can be installed indoors or outdoors, on the wall or on the ground. A generator, on the other hand, is usually larger, heavier, and louder than a home battery backup, and requires a dedicated outdoor space, a concrete pad, and a proper ventilation system. For example, a Tesla Powerwall weighs around 276 pounds and has a dimension of 45.3 x 29.6 x 5.75 inches, while a Generac Guardian weighs around 450 pounds and has a dimension of 48 x 25 x 29 inches .

However, the installation process and requirements of a home battery backup and a generator also depend on the local codes and regulations, as well as the availability and quality of the contractors. You may need to obtain permits, inspections, and approvals from the authorities before installing a backup power solution. You may also need to hire a licensed and experienced contractor to perform the installation safely and correctly. Therefore, it is important to do your research and consult with a professional before choosing and installing a backup power solution.

Maintenance

Another factor to consider when choosing a backup power solution is the maintenance needs and frequency. The maintenance needs and frequency of a home battery backup and a generator can also differ depending on the usage, condition, and performance of the product. Generally speaking, a home battery backup tends to have lower maintenance needs and frequency than a generator. This is because a home battery backup has fewer moving parts and less wear and tear than a generator, and can be monitored and controlled remotely via a smartphone app. A generator, on the other hand, has more moving parts and more wear and tear than a home battery backup, and requires regular testing, cleaning, and servicing. For example, a generator may need to be checked every month, serviced every six months, and replaced every 10 to 15 years, depending on the usage and model. A home battery backup may only need to be checked every year, serviced every five years, and replaced every 10 to 20 years, depending on the usage and model.

However, the maintenance needs and frequency of a home battery backup and a generator also depend on the potential issues and risks that may arise from the operation and storage of the product. You may encounter problems such as battery degradation, overheating, leakage, corrosion, short circuit, fire, explosion, noise, vibration, emission, or fuel spillage. Therefore, it is important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and recommendations, and to contact a qualified technician if you notice any signs of trouble.

Performance

Another factor to consider when choosing a backup power solution is the power capacity and duration. The power capacity and duration of a home battery backup and a generator can also differ depending on the size, type, and configuration of the product. Generally speaking, a generator tends to have a higher power capacity and duration than a home battery backup. This is because a generator can produce electricity as long as there is fuel available, while a home battery backup can only supply electricity as long as there is charge available. For example, a generator can provide up to 22 kilowatts of power, enough to run most of the appliances and devices in a typical home, while a home battery backup can provide up to 5 kilowatts of power, enough to run some of the essential appliances and devices in a typical home .

However, the power capacity and duration of a home battery backup and a generator also depend on the factors that affect the demand and supply of electricity, such as the size and load of your home, the weather and season, the frequency and duration of power outages, and the availability and cost of fuel or solar energy. Therefore, it is important to assess your power needs and preferences, and to choose a backup power solution that can meet them.

Conclusion

In conclusion, home battery backup and generator are both viable options for providing backup power to your home when the grid is down. However, they have different pros and cons that you need to weigh before making a purchase. Here is a summary of the main points of comparison between home battery backup and generator:

Factor Home Battery Backup Generator
Upfront Cost Higher Lower
Ongoing Cost Lower Higher
Installation Simpler More complex
Maintenance Lower Higher
Performance Lower Higher

The best backup power solution for you depends on your situation and preferences. If you value a lower ongoing cost, a simpler installation, a lower maintenance, and a cleaner and quieter operation, you may prefer a home battery backup. If you value a higher power capacity and duration, a lower upfront cost, and a more reliable and consistent operation, you may prefer a generator.

To help you make an informed and personalized decision, we recommend that you contact us at our website, where we sell high-quality and affordable home battery backup and generator products. We can provide you with more information, advice, and assistance regarding your backup power needs. We can also offer you a free consultation and a quote for your backup power solution. We look forward to hearing from you soon.

Back to blog