Solar Battery vs. Generator: Which One is Better for Your Home and Why? - SHIELDEN

Solar Battery vs. Generator: Which One is Better for Your Home and Why?

Introduction

If you are looking for a backup power source for your home, you may have considered two options: solar battery and generator. Both of them can provide electricity when the grid is down or unreliable, but they have different features, advantages, and disadvantages. How do you decide which one is better for your home and why?

In this blog post, we will compare solar battery and generator in terms of cost, performance, safety, compatibility, durability, and customer reviews. We will also provide a clear and balanced recommendation based on the evidence and criteria. By the end of this post, you will have a better understanding of the pros and cons of solar battery and generator, and be able to make an informed decision for your home.

Cost

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the cost. The cost of solar battery and generator can be divided into two categories: upfront and ongoing.

Upfront Cost

The upfront cost refers to the initial purchase and installation cost of the power source. The upfront cost of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the size, capacity, quality, and brand of the product.

Generally speaking, solar batteries are more expensive than generators in terms of upfront cost. According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost of a solar battery in the US is $11,840, while the average cost of a generator is $3,700. However, the upfront cost of solar batteries can vary widely depending on the type and number of batteries you need. For example, a Tesla Powerwall 2 costs $7,500, while a Sonnen ecoLinx costs $26,000.

Ongoing Cost

The ongoing cost refers to the maintenance and operation cost of the power source. The ongoing cost of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the frequency of use, the amount of power consumed, and the price of fuel.

Generally speaking, solar batteries have lower ongoing costs than generators, because they do not require fuel or frequent maintenance. Solar batteries can store excess energy from your solar panels or the grid, and use it when needed. The only ongoing cost of solar batteries is the replacement cost, which is usually after 10 to 15 years of use.

Generators, on the other hand, have higher ongoing costs, because they require fuel and regular maintenance. Generators can run on various types of fuel, such as gasoline, diesel, propane, or natural gas. The cost of fuel depends on the availability, demand, and price of the fuel in your area. According to Consumer Reports, the average cost of running a generator for 24 hours is $32 for gasoline, $44 for diesel, $48 for propane, and $18 for natural gas. Generators also need periodic oil changes, spark plugs, filters, and other parts, which can add up to the maintenance cost.

Potential Savings and Incentives

Another factor to consider when comparing the cost of solar battery and generator is the potential savings and incentives. Solar batteries can help you save money on your electricity bills, by reducing your dependence on the grid and allowing you to use cheaper or free solar energy. Solar batteries can also enable you to participate in net metering or time-of-use programs, where you can sell excess energy back to the grid or use it when the rates are lower.

Solar batteries can also qualify for tax credits, rebates, and other incentives, depending on your location and utility company. For example, in the US, you can claim a 26% federal tax credit for solar batteries if they are charged by solar panels and used for residential purposes. You may also be eligible for state, local, or utility incentives, such as the Self-Generation Incentive Program (SGIP) in California, which can cover up to 60% of the cost of a solar battery.

Generators do not offer the same level of savings and incentives as solar batteries, because they do not reduce your electricity bills or generate renewable energy. Generators are mainly used for backup power, not for daily use. Generators may also be subject to regulations and permits, depending on your location and type of generator. For example, in some areas, you may need to obtain a permit, install a transfer switch, and follow noise and emission standards for your generator.

Performance

Another factor to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the performance. The performance of solar battery and generator can be measured by the power output and efficiency.

Power Output

The power output refers to the amount of electricity that the power source can provide at a given time. The power output of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the weather, the load, and the battery life.

Solar batteries have a variable power output, depending on the amount of solar energy available and the state of charge of the battery. Solar batteries can provide power during the day and night, as long as they have enough stored energy. However, solar batteries may not be able to meet the peak demand of your home, especially if you have high-power appliances, such as air conditioners, heaters, or electric vehicles. Solar batteries typically have a power output range of 2 to 10 kilowatts (kW).

Generators have a fixed power output, depending on the size and capacity of the generator. Generators can provide power anytime, as long as they have enough fuel. However, generators may not be able to run continuously for long periods of time, especially if they overheat, run out of fuel, or need maintenance. Generators typically have a power output range of 3 to 20 kW.

Efficiency

The efficiency refers to the ratio of the useful energy output to the input energy. The efficiency of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the quality, age, and condition of the product.

Solar batteries have a high efficiency, because they convert solar energy into electrical energy with minimal losses. Solar batteries can also store excess energy for later use, reducing the waste of energy. Solar batteries typically have an efficiency of 85% to 95%.

Generators have a low efficiency, because they convert fuel into mechanical energy, and then into electrical energy, with significant losses. Generators also emit heat and noise, which are forms of wasted energy. Generators typically have an efficiency of 25% to 40%.

Safety

Another factor to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the safety. The safety of solar battery and generator can be evaluated by the environmental and personal impacts.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact refers to the effect of the power source on the natural environment, such as the air, water, and soil. The environmental impact of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the type, source, and disposal of the product.

Solar batteries have a low environmental impact, because they use renewable and clean energy from the sun. Solar batteries do not produce any harmful emissions, such as carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, or particulate matter, which contribute to global warming and air pollution. Solar batteries also have a long lifespan, which reduces the need for frequent replacement and disposal. However, solar batteries may contain toxic materials, such as lead, lithium, or cadmium, which can pose a risk if not handled or recycled properly.

Generators have a high environmental impact, because they use fossil fuels, such as gasoline, diesel, propane, or natural gas. Generators produce harmful emissions, such as carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter, which contribute to global warming, air pollution, and acid rain. Generators also have a short lifespan, which increases the need for frequent replacement and disposal. However, generators may use biofuels, such as ethanol or biodiesel, which are derived from renewable and organic sources, such as corn or soybeans.

Compatibility

Another factor to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the compatibility. The compatibility of solar battery and generator refers to how well they work with your existing solar panels, appliances, and grid connection.

Solar Panels

The solar panels are the devices that capture and convert solar energy into electricity. The solar panels are essential for solar batteries, because they provide the source of energy for charging and discharging the batteries. The solar panels are not necessary for generators, because they use fuel to generate electricity.

Solar batteries and solar panels are usually designed to be compatible with each other, as long as they have the same voltage, current, and power ratings. However, some solar batteries may require specific types or brands of solar panels, such as the Tesla Powerwall 2, which only works with Tesla solar panels. Some solar batteries may also have limitations on the number or configuration of solar panels, such as the Sonnen ecoLinx, which can only support up to 16 kW of solar panels.

Generators and solar panels are not compatible with each other, because they have different modes of operation and output. Generators produce alternating current (AC) electricity, while solar panels produce direct current (DC) electricity. Generators run on demand, while solar panels run on availability. Generators and solar panels may interfere with each other, causing damage or inefficiency to the system.

Appliances

The appliances are the devices that consume electricity in your home, such as lights, fans, refrigerators, TVs, computers, etc. The appliances are important for solar batteries and generators, because they determine the amount and type of power you need.

Solar batteries and appliances are usually compatible with each other, as long as they have the same voltage, frequency, and power ratings. However, some solar batteries may not be able to handle high-power appliances, such as air conditioners, heaters, or electric vehicles, because they have limited power output and capacity. Some solar batteries may also have restrictions on the number or type of appliances, such as the Enphase Encharge, which can only support up to 10 circuits of appliances.

Generators and appliances are usually compatible with each other, as long as they have the same voltage, frequency, and power ratings. However, some generators may not be able to handle sensitive appliances, such as computers, TVs, or phones, because they produce unstable or dirty electricity. Some generators may also have limitations on the number or type of appliances, such as the Honda EU2200i, which can only support up to 1,800 watts of appliances.

Grid Connection

The grid connection is the link between your home and the utility company, which provides electricity to your home when your solar panels or generator are not enough. The grid connection is optional for solar batteries and generators, because they can operate independently or in parallel with the grid.

Solar batteries and grid connection are usually compatible with each other, as long as they have the same voltage, frequency, and power ratings. However, some solar batteries may require a special device, such as a smart inverter or a transfer switch, to synchronize and communicate with the grid. Some solar batteries may also have regulations or policies, such as net metering or time-of-use, that affect how they interact with the grid.

Generators and grid connection are not compatible with each other, because they have different modes of operation and output. Generators produce AC electricity, while the grid produces DC electricity. Generators run on demand, while the grid runs on availability. Generators and grid connection may create a dangerous situation, such as backfeeding or overloading, if not properly isolated and protected. Generators and grid connection require a transfer switch, which is a device that automatically switches between the two sources of power.

Durability

Another factor to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the durability. The durability of solar battery and generator refers to how long they last and how well they perform over time.

Lifespan

The lifespan refers to the expected or actual time that the power source can function before it needs to be replaced. The lifespan of solar battery and generator depends on several factors, such as the quality, usage, and maintenance of the product.

Solar batteries have a long lifespan, because they have no moving parts and low degradation. Solar batteries can last for 10 to 15 years, or more, depending on the type and brand of the battery. For example, a Tesla Powerwall 2 has a warranty of 10 years, while a Sonnen ecoLinx has a warranty of 15 years.

Generators have a short lifespan, because they have moving parts and high wear and tear. Generators can last for 3 to 5 years, or less, depending on the size and type of the generator. For example, a Honda EU2200i has a warranty of 3 years, while a Generac GP2200i has a warranty of 2 years.

Warranty

The warranty refers to the guarantee or promise that the manufacturer or seller provides for the power source. The warranty of solar battery and generator covers the repair or replacement of the product in case of defects or malfunctions.

Solar batteries have a long and comprehensive warranty, because they are expensive and complex products. Solar batteries usually have a warranty of 10 years or more, and cover the performance, capacity, and workmanship of the battery. For example, a Tesla Powerwall 2 has a warranty of 10 years and 70% capacity, while a Sonnen ecoLinx has a warranty of 15 years and 100% capacity.

Generators have a short and limited warranty, because they are cheap and simple products. Generators usually have a warranty of 2 to 3 years, and cover the parts, labor, and service of the generator. For example, a Honda EU2200i has a warranty of 3 years and unlimited hours, while a Generac GP2200i has a warranty of 2 years and 500 hours.

Customer Reviews

Another factor to consider when choosing between solar battery and generator is the customer reviews. The customer reviews are the opinions and feedback of the actual users of the power source, which can reflect the quality, performance, and satisfaction of the product.

Sources and Methods

The sources and methods refer to how and where the customer reviews are collected and analyzed. The sources and methods of customer reviews can affect the credibility, validity, and reliability of the information.

Solar batteries and generators have various sources and methods of customer reviews, such as online platforms, surveys, and ratings. Online platforms, such as Amazon, Home Depot, or Consumer Reports, allow customers to post reviews, ratings, and comments on the products they purchased. Surveys, such as JD Power, Solar Reviews, or EnergySage, allow customers to answer questions and provide feedback on the products they used. Ratings, such as Energy Star, UL, or BBB, allow customers to evaluate the products based on certain criteria and standards.

However, not all sources and methods of customer reviews are equally trustworthy and useful. Some sources and methods may have biases, errors, or frauds, such as fake reviews, paid reviews, or cherry-picked reviews. Some sources and methods may have limitations, such as small sample size, low response rate, or outdated information. Therefore, it is important to check the source and method of the customer reviews, and compare them with other sources and methods, before making a decision.

Themes and Issues

The themes and issues refer to the common and unique topics and problems that the customer reviews mention and address. The themes and issues of customer reviews can reveal the strengths and weaknesses of the product, as well as the expectations and needs of the customers.

Solar batteries and generators have different themes and issues in their customer reviews, depending on the product and the customer. However, some themes and issues are more frequent and relevant than others, such as the following:

  • Solar batteries: The customer reviews of solar batteries often focus on the performance, cost, and service of the product. Some customers praise the solar batteries for their high efficiency, low maintenance, and clean energy. Some customers complain about the solar batteries for their high upfront cost, low power output, and poor installation. Some customers also mention the incentives, savings, and regulations of the solar batteries, and how they affect their decision and satisfaction.
  • Generators: The customer reviews of generators often focus on the reliability, noise, and safety of the product. Some customers praise the generators for their consistent power, easy operation, and convenient portability. Some customers complain about the generators for their loud noise, frequent maintenance, and harmful emissions. Some customers also mention the fuel, warranty, and compatibility of the generators, and how they affect their choice and experience.

Conclusion

In conclusion, solar battery and generator are two different options for backup power for your home, and they have different features, advantages, and disadvantages. The choice between solar battery and generator depends on your preferences, needs, and budget.

If you are looking for a power source that is more environmentally friendly, cost-effective, and compatible, then solar battery may be a better option for you. Solar battery can help you reduce your carbon footprint, save money on your electricity bills, and use renewable energy from the sun. However, solar battery may not be able to meet your peak demand, especially if you have high-power appliances or live in a cloudy area. Solar battery also requires a high upfront investment, which may not be affordable for everyone.

If you are looking for a power source that is more reliable, powerful, and flexible, then generator may be a better option for you. Generator can provide you with consistent power, regardless of the weather or time of day. Generator can also handle high-power appliances and run for long periods of time. However, generator may produce noise, emissions, and waste, which can harm your health and the environment. Generator also requires fuel and maintenance, which can add up to the ongoing cost.

Back to blog